What Is School (Position Paper)
Submitted by jsweeny on Tue, 10/13/2009 - 16:01.
Julia Sweeney
Modern Educational Theory- “What is School” Position Paper
School. A words some kids dread to hear. A word that can mean “prison” to some and “sanctuary” to others. A word commonly referred to in reference to systems and institutions. Analyzing and understanding the complex and different visions ofwhat school can be has helped me decide my vision of school and what it shouldbe.
School should not feel forced. It should be a place where students feel comfortable to be themselves and can express what they are learning in multiple ways. Itshould be a place where teachers and learners work together to take on bothroles. Its purpose is to inspire and to be an outlet of discovery. It can be aplace where students figure out what their talents and skills are. It is aplace of social, emotional and intellectual growth.
This school is a place that values respect. Values discovery. Values learning andvalues the learner. It values the teacher as a teacher and as a learner. This school does not base itself on one method or follow any one set of rules. It isa place of understanding and is full of understanding people. It gives equalopportunities to all of the students involved.
Thisschool benefits society in more ways than one. It manages to teach students the skills they need in the everyday world, the basics that all schools teach, and manages to teach different things that interest different students. They help students become individuals and find their talent, their skill. This school embraces working in and with the community, teaching how different studentswith different skills can help and can create change. These students leave this school and know how they can use their knowledge, their power and their talentsto help themselves and others. These learners know how they learn and what that learning differently than everyone else isn’t a bad thing. This school helps to inspire kids to help and to learn from others.
This school is good for the individual by supporting the individual. The school as a community helps inspire the individual so they can discover themselves as an individual. It creates a group of individuals who understand how they as an individual relate to others as well as themselves. It supports the individual and encourages the individual to be an individual.
Overall, this school differs from a “traditional” school, mostly in its strong support system and encouragement for the individual. It values things that a “traditional” school may regard as unimportant or unnecessary. It inspires more than a “traditional” school. It doesn’t have just one idea or one rule. It thrives on many and not on ONE.

I definitely agree that
I definitely agree that teachers and learners should take on both roles. However, not all teachers allow this to happen in their classrooms. Some teachers don't want kids to be the teachers, because they believe that they know more than the kids do and that their ideas are superior to theirs. It will benefit the students and teachers if they both can switch roles, because they can learn from each other. How could the school make sure that teachers are learners as well as teachers? I also agree that the individual should be emphasized, because everyone is different and everyone has different needs.
How would the school plan on
How would the school plan on helping the students do these things? What if the student doesn't find something they are good at then what?
Problematize
What are the practical ways of putting this into practice?
School
Hi Julia,
Your writing is pretty powerful in my humble opinion. Especially this:
"Its purpose is to inspire and to be an outlet of discovery. It can be aplace where students figure out what their talents and skills are. It is aplace of social, emotional and intellectual growth.
This school is a place that values respect. Values discovery. Values learning andvalues the learner. It values the teacher as a teacher and as a learner. "
and this:
"This school embraces working in and with the community, teaching how different studentswith different skills can help and can create change. These students leave this school and know how they can use their knowledge, their power and their talentsto help themselves and others. These learners know how they learn.."
The first comment suggested your vision of school sounds like SLA. Would you agree? In what ways does SLA meet your vision?
Best wishes,
Lani
While this is more broad, it
While this is more broad, it reminds me of SLA. In fact, all of the essays I have read so far, including mine, have reminded me of SLA. I wonder if, at least compared to the other current schools, we are "ideal."
Julia's Vision
I thought that your essay was really good and had great points in regards to a "traditional" school. I really like how you talk about not basing an institution on one set of rules and regulations. I agree with this because I believe that school shouldn't just be about rules and following them. I think schools should focus more on supporting students rather than disciplining them.
Post new comment